IT Brief New Zealand logo
Technology news for New Zealand's largest enterprises
Story image

LIFE, LIBERTY AND THE RIGHT TO SURF

By Contributor
Mon 1 Mar 2010
FYI, this story is more than a year old

As the internet permeates further into our daily lives and as more, seemingly vital, technologies operate only online, has access to the internet become a basic human right? Last year, section 92A of the Copyright (New Technologies) Amendment Act attracted controversy over the potential punishment of internet disconnection for repeat copyright infringement. Opposition to section 92A often centered on disconnection being a derogation of a basic human right.

Critics of the Act drew an analogy with the disconnection of a phone line or expulsion from the postal system. The internet has become so integral, the argument went, that disconnection was akin to cruel and unusual punishment. Across Europe many nations are struggling with the same issues. France, Finland, Estonia and Greece have all recently implemented laws making broadband internet a legal right. In Finland for example, all five million residents will be guaranteed access to a 1Mb broadband connection from July 2010.

However, this is not as radical as it first looks. When discussing the right to broadband access, the Finnish government specified that no household would be further than two kilometres away from a broadband connection and that around 2000 isolated households would not be included in the plan. If a ‘right’ to guaranteed access is satisfied merely by having a broadband connection in every neighbourhood, it seems a stretch to consider this as affirmation of a new human right. Leaving a discussion of the effectiveness of disconnection aside, a right to access does not include an absolute right notto be disconnected as a punishment.

By analogy, the right to liberty includes the right for the state to lock you up should you be found guilty of a serious crime.  Also, all ‘rights’ are not created equal; a legal right is not a human right. A legal right exists within a jurisdiction, guaranteeing standards that are common to all people within that discrete society. A human right exists everywhere, inherent in all of us.

Access to the internet, rather than being a right itself, is a tool that can help secure other rights. Just as the right to life carries with it an obligation on the state to have a criminal law and a competent police force, there is potential for online resources to become so integral to the guarantee of other rights, that access to those resources may oblige the state to ensure adequate internet access. Which is a question in itself: should the state be ultimately responsible for providing adequate internet access? Or should it be left to private enterprise and subject to market forces?

If, for example, the laws of a country are only readily available on the internet, access to the internet becomes integral to the right to a fair trial. Or if online voting systems replaced polling booths, a secure internet connection may be required to ensure that the right to participate politically is upheld. While human rights do change over time as society develops, and legal rights can become human rights through widespread practice and consensus, at this time it is a leap too far to call access to the internet a basic human right. It may be so in the future, but currently that is certainly premature. After all, if water remains heavily contested as a basic human right, can we really say that the internet is even close behind?

Related stories
Top stories
Story image
Tech job moves
Tech job moves - ARMA International, Avec, Komo & YouGov
We round up all job appointments from August 15-18, 2022, in one place to keep you updated with the latest from across the tech industries.
Story image
Microsoft
CCL launches Managed M365 offering for NZ work environments
CCL, the cloud specialist within Spark Business Group, has recently launched its Managed M365 offering.
Story image
Update
InterSystems releases updates to its IRIS data platform
Provider of next-generation solutions InterSystems has announced a series of new releases to its award-winning InterSystems IRIS data platform.
Story image
Cloud Security
Organisations struggling to secure new cloud environments
“In the wake of COVID-19, organisations substantially accelerated their digital transformation initiatives to accommodate a remote workforce."
Story image
Cloud
Microsoft accelerating NZ tech sector with new data centres
Microsoft’s forthcoming New Zealand data centres are introducing hyperscale public cloud capabilities on a scale previously unseen in the country.
Story image
LawVu
Exclusive: LawVu streamlines the in-house legal struggle
LawVu is a New Zealand-born company successfully transforming the in-house legal industry with its category-defining workspace.
Story image
Mobility
Micro-mobility companies caught at a crossroads - study
Reformulating models, operations and goals, shared micro-mobility companies can tap into a market worth US$9 billion in ride revenues in 2030.
Story image
SaaS
Cloudera launches all-in-one data lakehouse cloud service
CDP One makes it faster, easier and less risky for businesses to move to the cloud and migrate existing workloads to a modern data architecture.
Story image
Cryptocurrency
Crypto crime: Illicit activity falls with rest of market
Cryptocurrency scams, which typically present themselves as passive crypto investing opportunities, are less enticing to potential victims.
Story image
Storage
On-premise micro data centres an emerging option for storage
Digital transformation is occurring in all industries, resulting in unprecedented amounts of data. Explore the option of storing your information on-site using micro data centres.
Story image
MarTech
CM Group recognised as Best Overall MarTech Company
MarTech Breakthrough has ranked CM Group as the Best Overall MarTech Company for the third year running and Cheetah Digital as Best Overall Marketing Campaign Management Solution.
Story image
Facial recognition
Benefits vs risks of facial recognition technology
Once a distant, futuristic concept, facial recognition technology is now found in many technological applications with a variety of different functions. 
Story image
Business Intelligence / BI
TIBCO ranks highly in 2022 business intelligence study
Dresner Advisory Services has recognised TIBCO as a Service Leader and a Credibility Leader in Business Intelligence in the 2022 Wisdom of Crowds Business Intelligence Market Study.
Story image
Mobiles
Demand grows for future-proof mobile access solutions
HID Global, in partnership with IFSEC Global, recently released the 2022 State of Physical Access Control report for the fourth year running.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Concentric AI protects sensitive data with new capabilities
The new capability reveals sensitive data shared across email and business messaging platforms and highlights who has inappropriate access to content.
Story image
Gartner Magic Quadrant
Spryker named Gartner Visionary in 2022 Magic Quadrant for Digital Commerce
Spyker has announced it has been recognised by Gartner as a Visionary in the 2022 Magic Quadrant for Digital Commerce.
Story image
Banking
Virgin Money works with 9Spokes to create custom offering
Virgin Money has worked with Kiwi SaaS 9Spokes to build a custom version of its business dashboard offering, M-Track, to generate stronger insights for the bank and its customers.
Story image
Radware
DDoS activity rises dramatically - Radware report
The first six months of 2022 were marked by a significant increase in DDoS activity across the globe, according to a new report.
Story image
Digital Transformation
Federated change is the best path to digital evolution
Businesses that can successfully manage the exponentially expanding masses of data produced by modern consumers will be the businesses that survive and prosper.
Story image
Cybersecurity
CISOs need to consider a risk-based cybersecurity strategy
Rather than talking in terms of attack vectors and vulnerabilities, CISOs and security decision-makers must look at actual business risk.
Story image
Microsoft
8x more users attacked via old Microsoft Office vulnerability in Q2
"Criminals craft malicious documents and convince their victims to open them through social engineering techniques."
Story image
Cyber resilience
NZ’s Cyber Resilience Framework to be evolving and potentially automated
The government's already putting $2.4 million into the Cyber Resilience Framework in its initial stages, what is it and why is it important?
Story image
Blockchain
Australian Grand Prix uses CENNZnet blockchain for fan experience
CENNZnet was employed by Power'd Digital to deliver the Formula 1 Heineken Australian Grand Prix's 2022 AusGP Access program.
Story image
Collaboration
Schneider Electric launches Connected Services with Claroty
Schneider Electric is teaming up with Claroty to assist in maintaining cybersecurity for physical assets - a critical issue.
Story image
Hybrid Cloud
The essential guide to digital transformation by SolarWinds
Digital transformation is a buzzword thrown around all the time by companies, but what does it actually mean and why is it important? SolarWinds breaks it down.
Story image
Data Protection
Safeguarding your financial data
As the digital revolution marches on, managing data security has never been more important. Here are five important steps to take toward better financial data security.
Story image
Unified Communications
MAXHUB reveals latest innovations for ANZ at Integrate 2022 in Sydney
Some of the most exciting and innovative updates from this year's Integrate 2022 event have come from the leaders at MAXHUB.
Story image
Innovation
Arcion extends data replication platform with new capabilities
"Arcion is committed to investing in continuous innovation. Our goal is to be the first choice in whole-product solutions for large-scale data replication."
Story image
IDC
Collaboration app market revenue grows 28.4% year-over-year
IDC has found that global revenues in the collaboration applications market grew 28.4% year-over-year in 2021 to $29.1 billion.
Story image
Sustainability
CDC hyperscale data centres now open in New Zealand
CDC Data Centres (CDC) says two new, state-of-the-art hyperscale data centres are now open for business in Auckland.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Verizon supports Fujifilm's cybersecurity advancements
Verizon Business is supporting Japan’s Fujifilm Holdings to strengthen its global cybersecurity monitoring and cyber intelligence capabilities.
Story image
Data
Workday research finds A/NZ organisations becoming leaders in digital agility
New research from Workday and IDC has revealed that Australia and New Zealand are becoming leaders in digital agility.
AWS Marketplace
Learn how security orchestration, automation, and response (SOAR) enhances your security strategy.
Link image
Story image
Email scams
HelpSystems shines light on impact of response-based threats
Response-based attacks targeting corporate inboxes have climbed to their highest volume since 2020, representing 41% of all email-based scams.
Story image
Mobility
Cradlepoint launches architectural extension of NetCloud solution
With this latest release Cradlepoint is focused on helping lean IT organisations with advanced SD-WAN and zero trust capabilities.
Story image
Cybersecurity
‘Windows shops’ target admin rights to de-risk their environments
New data shows up to 75% of critical vulnerabilities could be mitigated through a rights and privileges crackdown
Story image
Contact Centre
Treasure Data launches new customer experience functionality
Treasure Data has introduced a new strategic vision and product positioning for Customer Data Cloud, reflecting the company's focus.
Story image
5G
Worldwide 5G mobile data traffic exploding - report
"With 5G, there is a wider range of deployment scenarios, forcing vendors to provide comprehensive solutions to support every need."
Story image
Customer experience
Exclusive: How Accenture is changing the customer experience game
Creating highly personalised real-world customer experiences using API, near-field communication, and spatial technology is about taking a traditional experience and elevating the customer journey into a digital world.
Story image
Environment
Lenovo launches CO2 Offset Service for SMBs across A/NZ
Lenovo has announced the rollout of a new, first-of-its-kind CO2 Offset Service for SMBs across Australia and New Zealand. 
Story image
Solutions
Ivanti reveals potential ROI of 261% for Endpoint Management Solution
Ivanti has announced the results of a commissioned Total Economic Impact (TEI) study conducted by Forrester Consulting.
Story image
Cloud
Whispir reports significant revenue growth as CaaS market expands
Australian cloud platform Whispir has announced its financial results, reporting significant growth as it continues to introduce new Communications-as-a Service (CaaS) offerings to the market.