Story image

Too soon for copyright infringement fee review

18 Apr 12

At the end of this month, submissions will close on a review of the fee which ISPs are able to charge copyright holders for sending out infringement notices under the Copyright (Infringing File Sharing) Amendment Act, which came into law in September.

The review, being undertaken by the Ministry of Economic Development, will evaluate whether the $25 fee is too much, too little, or just right, considering the amount of work required to issue the notices.

However, in a discussion of the issue a panel of ISP representatives have agreed that it’s too early to tell whether the fee is appropriate, given the surprising way the introduction of the Act has panned out.

Speaking at the TelCon12 telecommunications conference in Auckland today, TelstraClear’s Oonagh McEldowney, Vodafone’s Chris Abbot and CallPlus’ Graham Walmsley all indicated that preparing for the Act was a very expensive process.

"It’s more complex than just, ‘receive information, send notice’,” McEldowney says.

"We’re nowhere near recovering our setup costs.”

Walmsley adds, "there’s always a threat you’ll get thousands then a trickle.”

For starters, many rights holder groups are yet to request any notices, with nearly all requests so far coming from one group, the Recording Industry Association of New Zealand (RIANZ).

Furthermore, despite claims prior to the law’s passing that it would take thousands of infringement notices to tackle all the infringers in the country, most ISPs have reported only a few hundred notices at most, suggesting rights holders are only targeting the worst offenders.

TelstraClear CEO Allan Freeth yesterday confirmed that his company had just sent out its first ‘third strike’ notice, and Scott Bartlett, CEO of Orcon, said the same today.

Clare Curran, ICT spokesperson for the Labour party, says the responses of the ISPs indicate it is far too early to be conducting a review of the fee.

"What we need is some independent statistics on the economic effect the Act has had on the music industry,” Curran says, "and whether there’s been a drop in piracy.

"Despite the huge pressure [to pass the Act], we’ve seen no notices from the movie industry. Why is that? Is it the cost, or are they holding back for some other reason?”

As for the Act itself, Curran says there is a need to look into its effectiveness from the perspective of education and awareness of copyright issues.

McEldowney agrees, saying looking at the Act from a purely punitive perspective doesn’t tell the whole story.

"It all depends on what the rights holders were trying to achieve. If you’re trying to stop file sharing, it’s a bit like putting up a gate in a desert. But if you’re trying to educate people, there’s an argument it’s been effective.”

Go here for more on the review.

Dimension Data nabs three Cisco partner awards
Cisco announced the awards, including APJ Partner of the Year, at a global awards reception during its annual partner conference.
WatchGuard’s eight (terrifying) 2019 security predictions
The next evolution of ransomware, escalating nation-state attacks, biometric hacking, Wi-Fi protocol security, and Die Hard fiction becomes reality.
Rimini Street hits NZ shores with new subsidiary
The third-party support provider for Oracle and SAP has opened a new Auckland-based office and appointed Sean Jones as NZ senior account executive.
Why the adoption of SAP is growing among SMEs
Small and medium scale enterprises are emerging as lucrative end users for SAP.
Exclusive: How the separation of Amazon and AWS could affect the cloud market
"Amazon Web Services is one of the rare companies that can be a market leader but remain ruthlessly innovative and agile."
HPE extends cloud-based AI tool InfoSight to servers
HPE asserts it is a big deal as the system can drive down operating costs, plug disruptive performance gaps, and free up time to allow IT staff to innovate.
Digital Realty opens new AU data centre – and announces another one
On the day that Digital Realty cut the ribbon for its new Sydney data centre, it revealed that it will soon begin developing another one.
A roadmap to AI project success
Five keys preparation tasks, and eight implementation elements to keep in mind when developing and implementing an AI service.