IT Brief New Zealand logo
Technology news for New Zealand's largest enterprises
Story image

Is Vision Scapegoating keeping you from collaborative change?

Wed 8 Jun 2016
FYI, this story is more than a year old

Operational Dead Reckoning may help you get back on track, says Joe Auslander, senior agile consultant at Assurity Consulting.

Have you ever seen a group of people who believe they cannot collaboratively take action until they can collectively agree on the vision for their future?

It looks like a team of leaders who have worked for months to agree on the perfect delivery model, with little real change to show. It sounds like a cacophony of arguments about what we should name the different structures and teams in the future. It feels less like collaboration and more like begrudged collective territory sharing.

Welcome to Vision Scapegoating

This pattern is a descendant of the almighty Analysis Paralysis, where progress to a solution is blocked by the act of trying to develop the perfect plan before you begin – the major difference being that Vision Scapegoating specifically relates to groups of people and shifting the responsibility to collaborate from themselves to an agreed-upon vision of ‘a perfect future’ - illustrated as:

We won’t collaborate until we share the same vision of the future - versus - We will collaborate to discover our collective vision of the future.

There are many reasons and scenarios in which Vision Scapegoating can appear. In my experience, it often emerges from the best intentions slamming into old behaviours.

Here is an example:

A large international company needs to become more competitive in the market. They’ve spent decades building their business to be stable and careful moving. Now they say they want to become more flexible and be able to pivot quick with change in their market. A few ‘People In Charge’ (PICs) are asked to lead the change to make their environment more agile and are given support to do so. They look into the talent pool around and hire experts who paint a beautiful picture of what the future could be.

The PICs are told legends about other large organisations which are universally renowned as profitable leaders. These organisations are working in ‘X model’ or ‘X framework’ and all of their people are happy and productive and no one tells them how to dress to work.

The PICs listen as their hired experts tell them they will have to completely change the way they think about their organisation. Job titles will change, they will have to become a different kind of leader, people may be let go, new tools will have to be used… they may even have to stop wearing suits!

While the PICs recognise this Utopian future is exactly what they are being asked to produce, they also begin to understand the cost of what this change will bring. They play around with where to begin and quickly realise any first step will begin to unravel the business as they understand it. They begin to feel dread at the dawning of how fragile their environment is. The change their company needs is extremely complex and ripe with risk.

The PICs begin reading articles, calling experts, visiting other companies who are ‘already doing it’ and ideas begin to flow. Each PIC starts bringing their own versions of the future to the table. Hours and days of independent research has bolstered the belief that each of them have the right answer and can lead the first steps forward. As they begin to share their visions – even though they all agree that they want a beautiful utopia – for some reason they can’t seem to agree about what it will look like. When they share their plans, it seems like they are speaking different languages.

The PICs quickly move to drawing pictures which helps to focus the conversation, but as they begin to agree what they are talking about, their collective attention exposes flaws in any design that’s proposed.

Months go by as the model changes with every new bit of resistance. In fact, now there are several different models circulating and gathering troops – each model aligning to a particular PIC’s function. The PICs start to feel less like they are working together and more like they are blocking each other. When it is clear that no movement is happening and the PIC’s leaders ask why progress is so slow, the first bold PIC (often with the most people) steps into the space, uses their authority and ‘implements’ their model. Hands are thrown high as the loudest dysfunctions begin to emerge. Everyone feels like they are fighting fires, but it’s progress right? Why is it so painful?

The new standard becomes ‘whoever creates the change controls the space’ and now all of the PICs begin to tweak their environments to what they think is the perfect model. Clearly, it is so perfect that the others will thank them later for just going on ahead. They begin putting names on this change, using a large dictionary of new-found terms to explain structures they don’t have a definition for yet. If they name it, they own it.

They begin hearing that many of their direct reports are fighting with their colleagues’ direct reports and heels dig in. The need to protect their own becomes imperative and they give focused support down their functions. If they’re lucky at this point, they will see the need and begin to centre their attention in a collaborative way. If they are not, their kingdoms may pull themselves apart.

I’ve seen variations of this scenario at most of the companies I’ve worked with in the past and I believe it’s ripe with lessons.

First is the recognition that for any organisation trying to become more agile or lean, this sort of story (did this sound eerily familiar to you?) is normal, natural and ironic. Almost everyone I’ve worked with or talked to in this arena is looking for a big-bang solution to become more iterative.

Second is that these teams will build up extreme pressure to justify the first bit of change. It’s almost like there is a group subconscious at work saying “We are just too unsure to start changing things. If we increase the pressure in our environment to change, the need to change will justify the risk and we limit liability”. Which, on one hand is good, because things begin changing, on another it likely increases the risk they were so concerned about in the beginning.

I’m not a huge fan of the word ‘dysfunctional’. When something is labelled dysfunctional, you tend to view it as something that ‘should not be’. I find that this natural thought process limits my ability to understand and learn what is in front of me. I become more concerned about the thing not being what it should be and don’t pay attention to what it actually is.

I’d like to propose that we don’t see Vision Scapegoating or the behaviours that may come with it as a positive or negative thing, but rather a functional pattern that comes from the best intentions and can serve a purpose. Any repeatable pattern can be used to get an outcome. If that is my outlook, then my observations can leave the ‘that shouldn't be’ category and can become about two important questions:

Are we using the pattern or is it using us? If you find yourself in a situation where you suspect Vision Scapegoating may be using you, there is an alternative pattern that may help.

Operational Dead Reckoning

This comes from the mariner phrase ‘dead reckoning’, a practice where you calculate your position by estimating your direction and distance travelled from your last measurement. It’s often used when stable landmarks are not available and you need to know how you are tracking towards your destination (developed well before GPS).

Operational Dead Reckoning is where you calculate the direction and speed of change by measuring your current operational state at regular, short, increments and then reflecting on that change. You can think of it as a GPS for your business change that you can use to track if you are still progressing towards desired outcomes.

Operational Dead Reckoning takes the argument away from ‘Is it the right future operational model?’ to ‘Where are we now and what’s the next outcome we’d like to develop?’. The team can then have several future state operational models and test the effectiveness of them by introducing small incremental organisational change.

Truth is, Operational Dead Reckoning is useful even if you don’t have Vision Scapegoating. It makes building a cross-functional leadership team easier. It encourages discussion and experimentation. It also can be used as a tool to bring transparency to – and manage change – with stakeholders and constituents, with a minimum amount of effort.

Also, it’s not an entirely new concept. Lean Change Management and other scaled agile and lean approaches tackle the subject in different ways. What I’ve noticed though is, in reviewing different models and delivery philosophies, it’s easy to miss the ‘why we do it’ bit. Without having an experienced coach or extremely insightful leader on staff, many of the ceremonies or practices each scaled solution presents at this level can seem like you are just going through the motions. Operational Dead Reckoning should bring transparency to the operating model, as well as the buy in of the people who are a part of it.

My hope with this article is to lightly explore Vision Scapegoating and Operational Dead Reckoning, both functional patterns but with different outcomes, and throw it back to the readers to share their insights into these two topics.

What sort of scenarios have you seen that have lead up to Vision Scapegoating in places you have worked or are working? Has your organisation incrementally and collaboratively tracked its change towards desired outcomes during a transformation? If so, how was it implemented?

Article by Joe Auslander, senior agile consultant at Assurity Consulting.

Related stories
Top stories
Story image
Tech job moves - Forcepoint, Malwarebytes, SolarWinds & VMware
We round up all job appointments from May 13-20, 2022, in one place to keep you updated with the latest from across the tech industries.
Story image
Let’s clear the cloud visibility haze with app awareness
Increasingly, organisations are heading for the cloud, initiating new born-in-the-cloud architectures and migrating existing applications via ‘lift and shift’ or refactoring.
Story image
Remote Working
Successful digital transformation in the hybrid work era is about embracing shifting goalposts
As organisations embraced remote working, many discovered they lacked the infrastructure needed to support history’s first global load test of remote work capabilities.
Story image
Vectra AI
Understanding the weight on security leader’s shoulders, and how to shift it
Millions of dollars of government funding and internal budgets are being funnelled into cybersecurity to build resilience against sophisticated threats, indicating how serious this issue has become.
Story image
Digital Transformation
The impact of COVID-19 on healthcare environments and care delivery
The COVID-19 pandemic has revolutionised the healthcare industry while overcoming staff shortages, social distancing requirements, and lockdowns.
Story image
Amazon Web Services / AWS
RedShield leverages AWS to scale cybersecurity services
"Working with AWS gives RedShield the ability to mitigate significant application layer DDoS attacks, helping leaders adopt best practices and security architectures."
Story image
Nozomi Networks
Nozomi Networks, Siemens reveal software integration
Nozomi Networks and Siemens have extended their partnership by embedding Nozomi Networks’ software into the Siemens Scalance LPE local processing engine.
Story image
Cloud Security
Aqua Security createa unified scanner for cloud native security
“By integrating more cloud native scanning targets into Trivy, such as Kubernetes, we are simplifying cloud native security."
Story image
Cradlepoint expands its Cellular Intelligence capabilities
Cradlepoint has announced additional Cellular Intelligence capabilities with its NetCloud service.
Story image
Meadows exits Ingram Micro New Zealand on a good note
We look at the resignation of Danny Meadows from Ingram Micro's New Zealand Unified Communications & Collaboration business unit.
Story image
Cybersecurity starts with education
In 2021, 80% of Australian organisations responding to the Sophos State of Ransomware study reported being hit by ransomware. 
Story image
A10 Networks finds over 15 million DDoS weapons in 2021
A10 Networks notes that in the 2H 2021 reporting period, its security research team tracked more than 15.4 million Distributed Denial-of-Service (DDoS) weapons.
Story image
Revenue operations is taking centre stage
As the business world continues to evolve, new demands need to be met to keep up with the ever-changing landscape. 
Find out how a behavioural analytics-driven approach can transform security operations with the new Exabeam commissioned Forrester study.
Link image
Threat actors are exploiting weaknesses in interconnected IT/OT ecosystems. Darktrace illuminates your entire business and takes targeted action to stop emerging attacks.
Link image
Story image
Fonterra to use automated guided vehicles by Dematic
New Zealand's dairy giant Fonterra is upgrading its manufacturing facility in Edendale with new automated guided vehicles (AGVs) from Dematic.
Story image
Application Security
What are the DDoS attack trend predictions for 2022?
Mitigation and recovery are vital to ensuring brand reputation remains solid in the face of a Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attack and that business growth and innovation can continue.
Story image
Digital Transformation
The Huawei APAC conference kicks off with digital transformation
More than 1500 people from across APAC have gathered for the Huawei APAC Digital Innovation Congress to explore the future of digital innovation.
Story image
Supply chain
Jetstack promotes better security with supply chain toolkit
The web-based resource is designed to help organisations evaluate and plan the crucial steps they need to establish effective software supply chain security.
Story image
NCSC advisory highlights poor security configurations
The GCSB's National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) has released a cyber security advisory identifying commonly exploited controls and practices.
Story image
New Relic enters multi-year partnership with Microsoft Azure
New Relic has announced a strategic partnership with Microsoft to help enterprises accelerate cloud migration and multi-cloud initiatives. 
Story image
Digital Transformation
Pluralsight and Ingram Micro Cloud team up on cloud initiative
Pluralsight has teamed with Ingram Micro Cloud to build upon cloud competence and maturity internally, and externally support partners’ capabilities.
Story image
Wireless Nation
Wireless Nation, N4L provide 4G network to remote NZ schools
Wireless Nation and Network for Learning (N4L) have rolled out the Rural Connectivity Group’s (RCG) new 4G network to better connect three Chatham Islands schools.
Story image
New vulnerabilities found in Nuspire’s Q1 2022 Threat Report
“Threat actors are quickly adjusting their tactics and these exploits tend to get industry attention, but the threat posed by older and attacks still persists."
Story image
A third of companies paying ransom don’t recover data - report
Veeam's report finds 76% of businesses who are victims of cyberattacks paid the ransom to recover data, but a third were still unable to get their information back.
Story image
Apple previews new features for users with disabilities
Apple says new software features that offer users with disabilities new tools for navigation, health and communication, are set to come out later this year.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
AI-based email security platform Abnormal Security valued at $4B
"A new breed of cybersecurity solutions that leverage AI is required to change the game and stop the rising threat of sophisticated and targeted email attacks."
Story image
Grasping the opportunity to rethink the metrics of a sustainable data centre
A data centre traditionally has two distinct operations teams: the Facility Operations team, and the IT Operations team. Collaboration between them is the key to defining, measuring, and delivering long-term efficiency and sustainability improvements.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
How to ensure ethical deployment of AI implementations
The increase in automation and machine technology such as AI and machine learning has unlocked a whole new level of scale and service to organisations. 
Story image
ChildFund launches new campaign to protect children online
ChildFund says WEB Safe & Wise aims to protect children from sexual exploitation and abuse online while also empowering them to become digitally savvy. 
Booster Innovation Fund. A fund of Kiwi ingenuity – for Kiwi investors.
Link image
Story image
Data Center
Preventing downtime costs and damage with Distributed Infrastructure Management
Distributed Infrastructure Management (DIM) can often be a lifeline for many enterprises that work with highly critical ICT infrastructure and power sources.
Story image
Alarming surge in Conti Ransomware Group activity - report
A new report has identified a 7.6 per cent increase in the number of vulnerabilities tied to ransomware in Q1 2022.
Story image
Customer experience
Research unveils precarious customer loyalty for retailers
New research has found customers are reassessing established brand loyalties as their priorities and behaviours shift.
Story image
Data Protection
Barracuda launches new capabilities for API Protection
"Every business needs this type of critical protection against API vulnerabilities and automated bot attacks," Barracuda says.
Story image
Sift shares crucial advice for preventing serious ATO breaches
Are you or your business struggling with Account Takeover Fraud (ATO)? One of the latest ebooks from Sift can provide readers with the tools and expertise to help launch them into the new era of account security.
Story image
Digital Transformation
How to modernise legacy apps without compromising security
At a time when digital transformation has become central to business, even the most important applications come with a ‘use-by’ date.
Story image
Data backup plans inadequate, data still at risk - study
The Apricorn 2022 Global IT Security Survey revealed that while the majority organisations have data backup plans in place, data for many are at risk.
Story image
Power at the edge: the role of data centers in sustainability
The Singaporean moratorium on new data center projects was recently lifted, with one of the conditions being an increased focus on power efficiency and sustainability.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
SAS announces new products amid cloud portfolio success
Analytics and AI company SAS is deepening its broad industry portfolio with offerings that support life sciences, energy, and martech.
For every 10PB of storage run on HyperDrive vs. comparable alternatives, an estimated 6,656 tonnes of CO₂ are saved by reduced energy consumption alone over its lifespan. That’s the equivalent of taking nearly 1,500 cars off the road for a year.
Link image
Story image
More than 40% of banks worried about cloud security - report
Publicis Sapient's new report finds security and the lack of cloud skills and internal understanding of business benefits are big obstacles for banks moving to the cloud.
Story image
Could your Excel practices be harming your business?
While Excel has been the de-facto standard for budgeting, planning, and forecasting, is it alone, enough to support organisations in the global marketplace that’s facing rapid changes due to digital transformation?
Story image
Rubrik Security Cloud marks 'next frontier' in cybersecurity
"The next frontier in cybersecurity pairs the investments in infrastructure security with data security giving companies security from the point of data."